Showing posts with label facebook. Show all posts
Showing posts with label facebook. Show all posts

Monday, 18 March 2013

Facebook penalising 'link posts', but by how much? About 240%



We've all heard that Facebook penalises some posts, right?

It's been clear for some time now that Facebook affords posts that encourage activity within Facebook more reach than those that drive users away from Facebook (ie - posts that link to your website), but what exactly is the difference in reach between a post that has a link that drives users off-site, and a call to action that keeps users chatting within Facebook?

According to a test I've conducted, it's about 240%

Now, this figure is the result of one, non-scientific test. I will be conducting more tests, but the stats are interesting and demand further exploration. The raw data from my test is available here.

Test set-up:


  • Posted a post to Facebook twice, one including a link, the other a carbon copy of the first post minus the link.
    • The linked post was targeted to Facebook Page fans aged 13 -34, a potential reach of 8,200. It was posted on March 14 at 11:58am and is available here
    • The post without the link was targeted to Facebook Page fans aged 35 - 65+, a potential reach of 7,160. It was posted on March 14 at 12:00pm and is available here 

Test results:

  • There was a massive difference in levels of reach and engagement between the posts.
    • The linked post had a potential reach of 8,200, but only reached 2,128. The non-link post had a potential reach of 7,160 and reached 7,251 (The 100%+ reach is probably due to the level of likes, comments and shares resulting in the post reaching an even wider audience)
    • The linked post generated one comment, 27 likes and three shares. The non-linked post generated 17 comments, 67 likes and 43 shares.

Test flaws:

As I said before, this test is not scientific, there are a number of reasons why my results/data might be skewed:
  1. I've targeted two very distinct age groups. They may have very different typical levels of response to Facebook posts.
  2. The post that I posted second came out on top - Does this have any impact on the stats (despite that fact that the posts were targeted to two different audiences)?
  3. The post itself may have been a post that appeals more to an audience aged 35+.

Thoughts:

Despite all of the flaws with the test that I have pointed out above, the difference in reach, about 240%, is very, VERY significant. I need to conduct more tests before I come to any solid conclusions but the data above strongly suggests that Facebook heavily penalises posts that drive traffic away from Facebook.

You can help:

Do you have relevant data you can share? It would be great to get a broader overview of the impact of links on the reach of Facebook posts if you can share data from the Facebook Pages you manage.

Note: Obviously this requires further tests, and we should also test the impact of images and videos on reach and click-throughs. It isn't scientific, but it is very interesting.

Sunday, 3 March 2013

"Hi, you're bad at your job, buy our service" #SaleFail

Picture from FailFunnies.com
I took a really weak sales call last week, it went a little like:
Salesperson: "Hi Paul, I'm John Smith from Agency XYZ, we'd like to draft nine Facebook posts for you, free of charge, that will increase your engagement levels."
Me [In firm, confident tone, suggesting contempt]: "I think we're pretty well covered on that front."
Salesperson [slightly sheepishly]: "Oh....... ok. Goodbye."
Me: "Bye." 
Does this conversation sound familiar to you? I'm feeling a distinct sense of déjà vu. Sales calls like this come in far too regularly, and I'm convinced that rather than generate sales, those receiving these calls blacklist these companies.


Why do these calls fail? Well, there are a number of reasons:

You can't do your job


That's what that call said to me. John Smith was offering to do my job properly, because, y'know, I can't.

I know your community better than you do


I've spent almost two years getting to know the Girlguiding online 'community'. The more I've learnt, the more I've realised I have so much more to learn. The people that Follow us on Twitter and Like us on Facebook are a really diverse group of about 30,000 people, they are uniformally passionate and amazing people, but they have a range of interests, cares and concerns. This salesperson implied that the experience I have gained in almost two years at Girlguiding was worthless in the face of his amazing post-writing, hyper-engagement powers.

Agency is better than in-house


Now, this might be contentious. I fully believe that agencies are great for all sorts of work. They bring new angles, fresh perspectives, and they are outside of any 'bubbles' that you may have developed from long-term in-house work. Even with social media, they can be great for developing amazing campaign-focused ideas (and all sorts of other stuff), but I am firmly of the belief that long-term 'community management' is something that should sit in-house. Your community manager needs time to learn about your organisation, and time to learn about your online communities. Community management is not something that should be farmed out to an agency bod with several other accounts that s/he manages.

Result


Another agency/service blacklisted.

Lesson


John Smith from Agency XYZ may have had a great service to sell me (I doubt it, but it's possible). It's unlikely we would have bought that in, but still, it may have been worth looking at. The thing is, we never looked at it because the salesperson went out of his way to offend me. 

If you have a great service, optimise your sales pitch. John Smith offended me within about three seconds, and the call ended within 10 seconds. Damage done.

What do you think? Have you had any interesting, offensive or hilarious #salefail calls?